Jun 7, 2012, 1:23 AM EST
For the second time in the past two months, Rick Pitino has urged one of his upperclassmen to transfer in an effort to get them more playing time.
Back in April, Jared Swopshire officially announced that he would be transferring to Northwestern where he would be allowed to play immediately (graduate transfer waivers and all). The reason given by Pitino for urging the move? He “would love for Swopshire play 32 minutes somewhere else than 10 minutes here.”
And on Wednesday, rising senior Stephen Van Treese officially announced that he would be leaving the Louisville program, ending speculation as to how the Cardinals would solve their scholarship problem with the addition of freshman Montrezl Harrell. But, as Van Treese told the Indy Star, the explanation given to Van Treese was differnt. “(Pitino) said he felt like I need to go somewhere and play and get 30 minutes a game,” he said. “That wasn’t going to happen here.”
Pitino is going to be ripped for this, especially considering the fact that it is coming on the heels of his decision to force George Goode out last season. It doesn’t help matters that, prior to the season, Pitino was already talking about how this would be Swopshire’s last season at Louisville. Or that last season, he needed three scholarship players — Elisha Justice, Kyle Kuric and Chris Smith — to become walk-ons.
This is, quite literally, the definition of oversigning.
And what makes the issue even more troublesome is the fact that the players Pitino is running off are getting “cut” due to injuries they’ve sustained. Swopshire nearly had his career ended by a gruesome groin injury he suffered after spending the 2009-2010 season as a Louisville starter. After a reasonably successful 2010-2011 campaign, there was reason to believe that Van Treese could have become a solid contributor in his final two years in the program. He played just three games this past season due to knee issues.
It would be one thing if Pitino came out and said that he is forcing these players to transfer by refusing to offer them a scholarship for next season. (Scholarships are only renewable for one-year.) Instead, he is saying that he is doing this because it is in the best interest of the players. Given the fact that both are struggling to see minutes at the college level while dealing with serious injuries, it is awfully presumptuous to think that playing 30 minutes a game in a lesser program is a better situation than being a member of a team playing for a national title.
Look, Pitino does have a point. With a front line consisting of Harrell, Gorgui Dieng and Chane Behanan, playing time was going to be tough to come by for Swopshire and Van Treese. On an individual level, it is probably better for the potential professional careers of those two players that they go to a place where they can have a chance to play a lot of minutes.
But why is the power in Pitino’s hands to make those decisions? And why is he allowed to force his dedicated upperclassmen to transfer when he can, at the same time, refuse to release them to the school they want to go to?
That’s why this rule is unfair.
I don’t have a major problem with Pitino telling Swopshire to transfer because they ran out of scholarships or asking Van Treese to leave because they brought in Harrell. They got cut because Louisville got better players. It sucks, but it happens.
My issue is with how easy it is for a coach to get rid of a player when things don’t work out while it is, comparatively, a potential nightmare for the player if he decides he wants to leave.
- Late Night Snacks: No. 7 Arizona, No. 11 Wichita State and No. 19 Baylor among Saturday’s big winners 1
- Did Gonzaga cost themselves a No. 1 seed with loss to BYU? 5
- Kaleb Tarczewski produces another quality outing as No. 7 Arizona beats No. 13 Utah 0
- Bubble Banter: Boise State, St. John’s, Dayton win the day; Texas, N.C. State lose; and Kansas State? 3
- No. 1 Kentucky moves to 29-0 with blowout win over No. 18 Arkansas 2
- No. 11 Wichita State wins the Missouri Valley by knocking off No. 10 Northern Iowa 1
- NCAA tournament berth the final step for St. John’s senior class 0
- Report: Former Louisville guard Chris Jones charged with rape, sodomy (12)
- You Make the Call: Was Texas guard Isaiah Taylor fouled on this drive? (12)
- Roy Williams calls out North Carolina fans following win over Georgia Tech (11)
- Bill Self crushed, Jamari Traylor targeted during Kansas State court storm (VIDEO) (11)
- Dez Wells, Melo Trimble lead No. 14 Maryland to upset of No. 5 Wisconsin (9)