Skip to content

Will an ‘overheard conversation’ change the tenor of the Shabazz Muhammad investigation?

Nov 15, 2012, 9:58 AM EST

ShabazzMuhammadHeadshot

The saga that is UCLA’s quest to get prized freshman Shabazz Muhammad cleared by the NCAA is one that has dragged on for quite some time. We’ve had a statement from the family disputing the governing body’s claims that Muhammad violated amateurism rules, but few could have expected what was released Wednesday night.

According to Baxter Holmes of the Los Angeles Times, lawyers representing Muhammad believe that because of a conversation overheard on a flight from Chicago to Memphis in early August the NCAA had its mind made up to declare Muhammad ineligible.

The individual with the loose lips is (or it could be “was” by this point) reportedly the boyfriend of the attorney who working the case for the NCAA:

The conversation came to light in an email from an attorney who said she was seated behind a man who was speaking loudly about the work of his girlfriend, an “attorney with the NCAA.”

The girlfriend, whom he identified as “Abigail,” was investigating Muhammad. The man made it clear that the NCAA would find Muhammad ineligible and not allow him to play this season, the email said. Abigail Grantstein, an assistant director of enforcement, is the NCAA’s lead investigator on the Muhammad case.

The attorney, who confirmed her story in a telephone interview with The Times on Wednesday, said in her email that she was concerned with the lack of confidentiality and “the cavalier discussion of this young man’s future being tossed about for everyone to hear.”

The attorney (who according to the Times asked that her name not be released) sent emails to Dennis Thomas, a former chairman of the NCAA’s infractions committee, UCLA and the lawyer representing the family in this case, Robert Orr.

The question: how much of an impact will this have on the appeal filed by UCLA on Muhammad’s behalf, which is set to be heard on Friday?

And will the impact be positive (the NCAA rules him eligible) or negative (they say to hell with it and uphold the ruling without giving it much thought)?

Whether or not this conversation actually took place is something that’s up for debate; an answer that only the people on the plane truly know. The goal of Muhammad’s representation is to show that the NCAA had its mind made up before they even heard the case, but would the NCAA ever admit to that?

The introduction of this conversation as evidence could be a last-ditch effort to get the NCAA to change course, a “Hail Mary” so to speak. And those tend to not have a very high rate of success.

Raphielle also writes for the NBE Basketball Report and can be followed on Twitter at @raphiellej. 

Latest Posts
  1. Late Night Snacks: Bubble teams Pittsburgh, LSU and Tulsa suffer home losses

    Mar 5, 2015, 1:22 AM EST

    AP Photo AP Photo

    Neither the Panthers nor the Tigers did themselves any favors Wednesday night, with Pittsburgh’s home loss being the costlier of the two defeats.

  2. Bubble Banter: Why LSU losing is bad news for Texas A&M

    Mar 4, 2015, 11:59 PM EST

    AP Photo AP Photo

    All of Wednesday’s relevant bubble info can be found right here.

  3. Joe O’Shea’s off-balance three-pointer forces overtime in Bryant’s double OT win over Sacred Heart (VIDEO)

    Mar 4, 2015, 11:34 PM EST

    Getty Images Getty Images

    Thanks to O’Shea the Bulldogs advanced to the NEC semifinals, where they’ll take on Robert Morris.

  4. Bonzie Colson continues hot streak as No. 12 Notre Dame wins at No. 16 Louisville

    Mar 4, 2015, 9:38 PM EST

    AP Photo AP Photo

    Colson and Demetrius Jackson scored 11 second-half points apiece in Notre Dame’s win at Louisville.

  5. Defense turns into instant offense for Ohio State’s Sam Thompson (VIDEO)

    Mar 4, 2015, 9:03 PM EST

    Ohio State v Michigan State Ohio State v Michigan State

    D’Angelo Russell scored 28 to lead the Buckeyes, but none of his points were wilder than the two scored by Thompson on this play.

  6. Semifinalists for Naismith Coach of the Year trophy announced

    Mar 4, 2015, 5:59 PM EST

    AP Photo AP Photo

    Kentucky head coach John Calipari is one of 15 coaches still in contention for this honor.

  7. Frank Kaminsky, Jahlil Okafor among ten semifinalists for Naismith Award

    Mar 4, 2015, 5:13 PM EST

    AP Photo AP Photo

    Kaminsky is one of five seniors on the list, and Gonzaga is the only program with two representatives.

  8. ‘First four out’ to receive one-seeds in Postseason NIT

    Mar 4, 2015, 4:20 PM EST

    AP Photo AP Photo

    With the higher seeds hosting in the first three rounds of the Postseason NIT, the four one-seeds could potentially not leave campus before the semifinals at Madison Square Garden.

  9. Updated NCAA tournament odds

    Mar 4, 2015, 3:40 PM EST

    Trey Lyles Trey Lyles

    The most recent title odds from Bovada.

  10. Potential Cinderellas you want to win their automatic bid

    Mar 4, 2015, 1:26 PM EST

    Cam Payne (AP Photo) Cam Payne (AP Photo)

    These are the small league favorites that can win a game in the NCAA tournament.

  11. Today is the 25-year anniversary of Hank Gathers’ death

    Mar 4, 2015, 11:51 AM EST

    spt-120203-kimble Getty Images

    Hank Gathers died on the court during the WCC tournament.

  12. Bill Self says Perry Ellis sprained knee, back in ‘a week or so’

    Mar 4, 2015, 10:42 AM EST

    (AP) AP

    Perry Ellis suffered a nasty looking knee injury last night.

  13. Virginia’s Justin Anderson could return as early as Saturday

    Mar 4, 2015, 9:41 AM EST

    Justin Anderson (Getty Images) Getty Images

    Justin Anderson has been out for more than three weeks after fracturing a finger.

  14. Missouri Valley Conference Tournament Preview and Postseason Awards

    Mar 4, 2015, 9:00 AM EST

    uni Getty Images

    Two strong teams enter the Valley Conference Tournament with numerous others trying to enter the frame.

  15. Karl Towns takes over, No. 1 Kentucky moves to 30-0

    Mar 4, 2015, 12:26 AM EST

    Getty Images Getty Images

    Kentucky is learning how to win games when they don’t play well. That’s scary.

  16. No. 9 Kansas rallies to beat No. 20 West Virginia in OT but injury to Perry Ellis is major concern

    Mar 3, 2015, 11:58 PM EST

    (AP) AP

    No. 9 Kansas topped No. 20 West Virginia but now the Jayhawks must worry about the health of Perry Ellis.