Skip to content

Properly evaluating Marcus Smart

Dec 11, 2012, 5:00 PM EST

Marcus Smart

If you missed it, there interwebs has played host to an entertaining discussion about Oklahoma State point guard Marcus Smart over the last day or two.

It started when John Gasaway ranked the freshmen and slotted Smart at 14th, which, according to Mike DeCourcy, is borderline certifiable, as he wrote, “People, Marcus Smart has been the best college player in the nation to this point”. Gasaway fired back, saying, essentially, that he had Smart that low for two reasons: 1) he’s not shooting the ball well for a player whose role is that important, and 2) he can and will play better before the season is out.

Frankly, I don’t think either of them are right as of right now.

I understand Gasaway’s point, but calling Smart the 14th best freshman in the country right now is ludicrous. I’d have Smart somewhere in the top three, along with Anthony Bennett of UNLV and Jordan Adams of UCLA. If you want to slide him down to sixth — behind Nik Stauskas, Ben McLemore and Semaj Christon — because you hate the fact that he’s shooting 45.3% from two and 20.6% from beyond the arc while shooting 23.9% of the possessions that he’s on the floor — or because he’s averaging 3.4 turnovers — than I’ll disagree with you, but at least I’ll understand where you’re coming from.

But you can’t have Smart as the 14th best freshmen in the country, just like you can’t call Smart the best college basketball player in the country to this point in the season.

Because that award belongs to Mason Plumlee, and it’s really not close.

Plumlee has finally turned all of his potential into production, averaging 19.2 points, 11.4 boards and 1.7 blocks while shooting 61.1% from the floor and 73.1% from the free throw line. He’s become Duke’s anchor on both ends of the floor, turning them into a team that lost to a No. 15 seed in the opening round of the 2012 NCAA tournament into one of the two best teams in the country. And Plumlee has posted these numbers while Duke has beaten Kentucky, Minnesota, VCU, Louisville, Ohio State and Temple.

Smart has changed the culture of that Oklahoma State team. He’s taken over a leadership role and gotten the Pokes through a pair of season-ending injuries. It’s not a coincidence that Le’Bryan Nash is starting to play up to his potential this season or that Oklahoma State is tougher on the defensive end of the floor. But Smart has led Oklahoma State to wins over Akron, Tennessee, NC State and South Florida and a loss at Virginia Tech.

Speaking of Virginia Tech, I also think I would rank Erick Green — the point guard that went for 28 points in the Hokie’s win over Smart’s squad — over him. Green is averaging 24.8 points and 5.0 assists while turning the ball over just 1.8 times per game while leading Tech to an 8-1 start that, quite literally, no one saw coming. Michael Carter-Williams, Doug McDermott, Jeff Withey and Trey Burke are all guys that deserve heavy consideration for the title “best player in college basketball this season”.

Smart’s been great.

No one is saying otherwise.

He’s an all-american as of now.

But I don’t think he’s the Player of the Year after the first month of the season.

Rob Dauster is the editor of the college basketball website Ballin’ is a Habit. You can find him on twitter @robdauster.

Latest Posts
  1. Weekly Awards: Temple, UNLV earn wins that will get them into bubble contention

    Dec 29, 2014, 9:00 AM EST

    Christian Wood (Getty Images) Getty Images

    It is not too early to start talking about the importance of non-conference wins.

  2. College Basketball Talk’s Latest Top 25: Arizona, Texas drop after losses

    Dec 29, 2014, 6:57 AM EST

    AP AP

    Who moved into the Top 10 this week and who dropped out?

  3. Sunday’s Snacks: St. John’s, Arizona State, Syracuse earn solid afternoon victories

    Dec 29, 2014, 12:12 AM EST

    D'Angelo Harrison AP

    Some solid afternoon victories for St. John’s, Arizona State and Syracuse.

  4. Stony Brook hands No. 13 Washington its first loss of the season

    Dec 28, 2014, 11:15 PM EST

    Steve Pikiell Steve Pikiell

    Despite trailing by as many as 16 points in the second half, Stony Brook managed to pick up its first-ever win over a ranked opponent.

  5. Former Stanford center to join Florida program as a walk-on

    Dec 28, 2014, 9:44 PM EST

    Billy Donovan AP

    Before deciding to attend Stanford, Schuyler Rimmer verbally committed to attend Florida in August 2012.

  6. Hawaii senior guard to undergo surgery on right hand

    Dec 28, 2014, 6:33 PM EST

    Garrett Nevels, Jaron Hopkins AP

    Garrett Nevels is averaging 12.0 points and 4.9 rebounds per game for the 10-4 Rainbow Warriors.

  7. Wild game-ending sequence pushes Texas Southern past Kansas State (VIDEO)

    Dec 28, 2014, 5:48 PM EST

    Mike Davis Mike Davis

    Eight days after winning at then-No. 25 Michigan State, Texas Southern scored six points in the final 3.8 seconds to stun Kansas State in Manhattan.

  8. UNLV’s Christian Wood throws down a nasty windmill (VIDEO)

    Dec 28, 2014, 2:35 PM EST

    wood Getty Images

    Christian Wood is one of the most improved sophomores in the country this season. This was just nasty.

  9. Fresno State hopes to get word on eligibility of point guard shortly

    Dec 28, 2014, 12:54 PM EST

    Cezar Guerrero AP

    Fresno State hopes to get word on a productive point guard soon.

  10. The five toughest games left on Kentucky’s schedule are uninspiring

    Dec 28, 2014, 11:11 AM EST

    Willie Cauley-Stein (Getty Images) Getty Images

    There’s a reason Kentucky will be expected to go 31-0 this season.

  11. Michigan basketball ticket prices surge in anticipation of potential Jim Harbaugh head coaching announcement

    Dec 28, 2014, 10:25 AM EST

    Caris LeVert, Lucas Grose AP

    Tickets for the Michigan and Illinois game on Tuesday have skyrocketed as Wolverine fans hope for an introduction to potential new football head coach Jim Harbaugh.

  12. Late Night Snacks: No. 1 Kentucky defeats No. 4 Louisville

    Dec 27, 2014, 11:40 PM EST

    Tyler Ulis (Getty Images) Getty Images

    There’s one less undefeated in college basketball as the Wildcats won at Louisville.

  13. Kevin Pangos, Kyle Wiltjer lead No. 8 Gonzaga past BYU

    Dec 27, 2014, 9:25 PM EST

    Kevin Pangos Kevin Pangos

    Wiltjer finished the game with 24 points and Pangos scored 18 of his 21 in the second half Saturday evening in Provo.

  14. North Carolina’s J.P. Tokoto finishes with authority in win over UAB (VIDEO)

    Dec 27, 2014, 8:41 PM EST

    AP Photo AP

    Tokoto made just one field goal in UNC’s 89-58 win over UAB. Unfortunately for UAB’s WIlliam Lee, he got in the way.

  15. Report: Former Duke forward transferring to SMU

    Dec 27, 2014, 6:01 PM EST

    Livingstone v Duke Getty Images

    Semi Ojeleye averaged 2.0 points and 1.3 rebounds per game during his time at Duke.

  16. Perimeter shot selection will be key for Louisville moving forward

    Dec 27, 2014, 5:31 PM EST

    Rick Pitino Rick Pitino

    Louisville’s starting perimeter (Rozier, Jones and Blackshear) combined to shoot 10-for-42 in their loss to No. 1 Kentucky.

  17. Tyler Ulis proves he’s Kentucky’s best point guard in 58-50 win over Louisville

    Dec 27, 2014, 4:44 PM EST

    Tyler Ulis (Getty Images) Getty Images

    But just because he’s their best point guard doesn’t mean he’s going to be their starter.