Skip to content

Who is the best college basketball team in the West?

Dec 26, 2012, 2:12 PM EDT

Elias Harris AP

With the Arizona-San Diego State matchup on Christmas night living up to its billing, it reopened an old conversation. Who is the best team in the West? Below takes a look at some contenders

The Contenders

No. 3 Arizona

The two biggest questions being asked of Sean Miller’s Wildcats are as follows: Can Mark Lyons be a reliable true point guard for the entire season? And how will the young Arizona front line hold up in the thick of Pac-12 play and into March?

Firstly, Lyons may not be a true point guard, but he is the team’s leading scorer and assist man. He ran into foul trouble against San Diego State, but he is a high-major caliber guard who can score the ball. The Wildcats aren’t “settling” by running Lyons at the point, but he is by far their best option and they wouldn’t be where they are today had he not transferred from Xavier in the offseason.

As for the youth, they’ll have their ups and downs and Tuesday night was a down. The freshman frontcourt trio of Kaleb Tarczewski, Brandon Ashley, and Grant Jerrett combined to go 3-of-9 for nine points. There are few front lines larger and more athletic than Arizona’s, but the key will be about maturity and experience.

That leads into the third major point: Kevin Parrom. Remember what Darius Miller did at Kentucky last season, how he was the senior leader in a group of young players? Parrom is taking on the same role at Arizona, as is evidence by his 17-point performance on 7-of-11 from the floor Tuesday night in a win over San Diego State.

No. 13 Gonzaga

Gonzaga was rolling through the early part of the season until it ran into a, Illinois team that was composed and hot from the floor on Dec. 8. Since that loss, the Bulldogs have won two straight, one a 16-point win over Kansas State (which later beat No. 8 Florida) and another double-digit win over Campbell.

Adding Kelly Olynyk into the mix after his suspension has been huge for Gonzaga, as he has averaged 14.6 points and 6.6 rebounds per game. Add him to frontcourt mate Elias Harris and there’s no wonder why the Bulldogs are third in the country in field goal percentage and in the Top 15 nationally in scoring.

No. 17 San Diego State

The most impressive part of San Diego State’s near-victory over Arizona is that they did it with only nine points from Jamaal Franklin. Not only does that speak to Franklin’s ability to affect the game in different ways (eight rebounds, six assists, one turnover), but it also highlights how underrated Chase Tapley has been for the Aztecs. His 19 points carried SDSU on Franklin’s off-night and showed his ability to carry a team when needed.

No. 20 UNLV

UNLV has been questioned about its youth as well, but Anthony Bennett has been the biggest answer so far for the Rebels. Not only has he been Freshman of the Year material, but he has also found his way into the National Player of the Year conversation. Dave Rice’s team took a hit when Mike Moser went down, but Pitt transfer Khem Birch has been an important player to back-fill the position. They will be battling with San Diego State for the Mountain West throughout conference play.

Daniel Martin is a writer and editor at, covering St. John’s. You can find him on Twitter:@DanielJMartin_

  1. trapshoot - Dec 26, 2012 at 3:37 PM

    Right now it’s probably Arizona, bot way too soon to really know who truly is the best.

  2. sbmcintosh36 - Dec 26, 2012 at 4:20 PM

    wayyyyy to early right now its the Cats and if the kids keep improving they will go deep in tourney….Bear Down!!!!

  3. realisticbeyondyou - Dec 26, 2012 at 4:46 PM

    Maybe the Arizona fans can learn some basic English between now and the NCAA tournament?
    Perhaps by then the Wildcats can exit by the first or second round – as usual – and not be a concern to anyone beyond their slim fanbase beyond the whacky racist state with only the Grand Canyon and Flagstaff as its two assets?

    • namriverrat69 - Dec 27, 2012 at 11:02 PM

      Maybe we read a different article. The article Daniel Martin wrote above made no mention of racism. Why is it that ignorant people who can’t put two intelliegent words together always try to impress the masses with faux intelligence by using the race card. How often it is the educated as well as the uneducated that no common sense.

      For that matter an education does not mean you have common sense and compassion for others in need. As a man who grew up in AZ in the 1950s & 1960s until 1968 when Vietnam changed my address for 4 years, I have always been in favor of helping all people in need regardless of they background and treating everyone equally. To all these complainers and hateful racist name callers: “In your life, what have your done to improve the quality of life of those around you, in your community or our nation?”

      Actually that is a paraphrase to some degree from John F. Kenney’s first Inaugural Speech on January 20, 1961. His speech said in part “Ask not what your country can do for you, but ask what you can do for your country”? To quote that these days is almost like committing treason.

      By the way, you forgot to mention the world famous, spectacular Collossal Cave.

      GO CATS!! And if and when they work out a CBA GO LA KINGS!!

  4. sbmcintosh36 - Dec 26, 2012 at 6:07 PM

    And maybe you can go troll on another story and suck it

  5. funktron2x - Dec 27, 2012 at 2:02 AM

    Nothing like a pompous, condescending voice uttering something like “whacky” to make everyone laugh their jewels off.

    I won’t even guess which team this clown is a fan of. There are too many programs staring up at Arizona to waste the time counting.

  6. tg1896 - Dec 27, 2012 at 7:58 AM

    Tim Tebow changes his socks and the report gets 437 comments. “Who’s the Best in the West?” garners six. Sounds about right.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!