Skip to content

Nerlens Noel’s knee injury and the unfairness of the ‘one-and-done’ rule

Feb 13, 2013, 9:22 AM EDT

Nerlens Noel

As of this morning, we don’t know the severity of the knee injury that Nerlens Noel, Kentucky’s star center and a likely candidate for the No. 1 pick in this June’s NBA Draft, suffered at Florida last night.

What we do know is that knees aren’t supposed to bend sideways to a 90-degree angle, and that anyone in enough pain to have their screams clearly audible on the television broadcast probably won’t be playing for a while. We can only hope that whatever happened inside that left knee is a) not too serious and b) somehow fixable.

(UPDATE: It’s official: Noel tore his ACL and, obviously, will be out for the rest of the season.)

Because the issue here isn’t that the Kentucky Wildcats lost their star center or that John Calipari’s team, the reigning national champions, now appear destined for the NIT. The bigger problem is that Noel’s knee isn’t a normal knee.

It’s a knee worth millions upon millions of dollars, one that an NBA General Manager is going to have to look at and decide whether or not it’s worth it to invest some $10-$14 million of guaranteed money in.

And that’s precisely why Noel should have never been in college in the first place. From Pat Forde:

The greater issue is Noel’s future, and the way it is put at risk by a system that forced him to play college ball for a year instead of going straight into the NBA draft.

Noel may have gotten hurt in 2013 no matter where he was playing, but at least he would be under contract and well-compensated by whatever NBA team would have drafted him in the first round last June.

Instead, he wound up playing for scholarship money at Kentucky. And while that is nothing to sneeze at, Noel’s presence on campus represents restraint of trade and a bastardization of what college is supposed to be.

He wants to be a pro basketball player. Let him be a pro basketball player without the charade of college delaying it. Unfortunately, that was not an easy option.

If this injury compromises Noel’s draft status, it’s on David Stern and his league’s minimum age requirement.

This is the worst-case scenario. This is the ‘what if?’ we’re always talking about. This is the No. 1 overall pick, a player that could have been banking seven-figures right now had the NBA not implemented the one-and-done rule, risking his livelihood because David Stern and his cronies ruled that a player be 19 and a year out of high school to be eligible for the draft.

The point that needs to be made clear here is that this is not college basketball’s fault. They have no control over what the NBA decides to do. In fact, I wouldn’t be surprised if Mark Emmert and company were pushing for the one-and-done rule to go away. It would take away the headache of some of those recruiting scandals while leaving the NCAA’s one true money-maker — the NCAA tournament — intact.

Maybe Noel’s knee-injury can be a catalyst for change in the next collective bargaining agreement, but that seems unlikely. The NBAPA is an unmitigated disaster right now, and those NBA owners want an extra year — maybe more — of scouting and evaluation and development before they decide to invest millions into an athlete. It’s their money, and they want every bit of information possible to ensure they’re spending it wisely; they want to know they’re spending it on a kid that’s going to be ready to contribute, not a player that needs the length of his rookie contract just to develop enough skill to break into the rotation.

That rule isn’t changing.

And it’s not fair.

So what can we do?

Continue to push for college athletes to be compensated properly by the NCAA? Push for more of the elite players to spend a season abroad? Tell them to avoid college all together and instead spend a year training to develop the rest of their all-around game (an NBA redshirt, if you will)?

Modern medicine has made it such that a blown-out knee is no longer a career-ending injury. Ask Adrian Peterson, who tore his ACL and MCL exactly a year before he nearly broke the single-season NFL rushing record. Ask Branden Dawson, who doesn’t look the slightest bit bothered despite having torn his ACL less than a year ago.

So even if Noel’s knee injury is a worst-case scenario, it’s not necessarily the end of his career.

But the fact that someone so valuable was even put at risk of an injury like this is a travesty.

Yet, there’s nothing that we can do about it than shake our fists and look on disapprovingly.

You can find Rob on twitter @RobDauster.

Latest Posts
  1. Class of 2015 four-star wing down to three schools according to report

    Jun 29, 2015, 10:05 PM EDT

    adidas adidas

    Maverick Rowan is reportedly focused on three schools.

  2. UCF guard will transfer

    Jun 29, 2015, 9:00 PM EDT

    ORLANDO, FL - FEBRUARY 15:  Brandon Goodwin #11 of the UCF Knights drives to the net during an NCAA basketball game between the Houston Cougars and the UCF Knights at the CFE Arena on February 15, 2014 in Orlando, Florida. UCF won the game 56-54. (Photo by Alex Menendez/Getty Images) Getty Images

    UCF is losing its third-leading scorer from last season to transfer.

  3. Fred Hoiberg makes surprise appearance at Iowa State fantasy camp (VIDEO)

    Jun 29, 2015, 6:00 PM EDT

    AP AP

    Former Iowa State head coach Fred Hoiberg returned to Hilton Coliseum to give one final pre-game speech before a fantasy camp.

  4. Re-ranking recruiting classes: Who are the 25 best players from the Class of 2004?

    Jun 29, 2015, 4:52 PM EDT

    Getty Images Getty Images

    It should not be a surprise who the best player from this class ended up being.

  5. Bo Ryan to retire from Wisconsin after next season

    Jun 29, 2015, 1:40 PM EDT

    AP Photo AP Photo

    Ryan has never finished below fourth in the Big Ten.

  6. St. John’s lands Italian guard, eighth member of 2015 recruiting class

    Jun 29, 2015, 12:45 PM EDT

    AP Photo AP

    Mullin has completely turned over the St. John’s roster.

  7. So what happened to the chair Bobby Knight threw in 1985?

    Jun 29, 2015, 11:27 AM EDT

    Getty Images Getty Images

    Knight’s most famous outburst may be lost to history.

  8. USA Basketball: 16 college players to tryout for the Pan-Am Games

    Jun 29, 2015, 10:26 AM EDT

    USABasketballlogo

    There are 22 total players participating in the trials.

  9. UCLA lands four-star center, second 2017 commitment

    Jun 29, 2015, 8:00 AM EDT

    Steve Alford AP

    Steve Alford now has a pair of 2017 commitments.

  10. LSU lands commitment from in-state star

    Jun 28, 2015, 6:29 PM EDT

    AP Photo AP Photo

    Johnny Jones has done an excellent job of recruiting his state in recent years.

  11. South Florida gets transfer guard from Big Ten program

    Jun 28, 2015, 4:00 PM EDT

    Penn State's Geno Thorpe (13) drives against Iowa's Melsahn Basabe on Saturday, Feb. 15, 2014, at the Bryce Jordan Center in State College, Pa. Iowa won, 82-70. (Abby Drey/Centre Daily Times/MCT via Getty Images) Getty Images

    South Florida brought in an experienced guard who can contribute after sitting out a transfer season.

  12. Robert Carter has dropped nearly 20 pounds during time at Maryland

    Jun 28, 2015, 2:45 PM EDT

    robert carter Getty Images

    Maryland transfer Robert Carter has worked on his conditioning since arriving from Georgia Tech.

  13. USA U19 team beats Croatia in FIBA World Championships

    Jun 28, 2015, 1:19 PM EDT

    Getty Images Getty Images

    The USA U19 team is off to a 2-0 start at the FIBA World Championships.

  14. Four-star Class of 2016 big man cuts his list to 10

    Jun 28, 2015, 11:45 AM EDT

    (Scott Phillips/NBCSports.com) (Scott Phillips/NBCSports.com)

    A top-100 player in the Class of 2016 is down to 10 schools.

  15. Syracuse lands transfer center from the Big East

    Jun 28, 2015, 10:15 AM EDT

    (AP) AP

    Syracuse picked up a transfer big man that should help in the future.

  16. Mixtape of four-star Class of 2017 guard Trae Young (VIDEO)

    Jun 28, 2015, 9:15 AM EDT

    Nike Elite Youth Basketball League Getty Images

    Trae Young has been one of the best players of spring.

  17. UNCG placed on two years probation for NCAA rules violations

    Jun 27, 2015, 9:05 PM EDT

    UNCG Athletics UNCG Athletics

    The violations weren’t deemed severe, but the sheer number of them led to the NCAA adding a second year of probation.