Skip to content

The NCAA ‘did not violate a specific bylaw’ in their investigation into Miami?

Feb 18, 2013, 4:14 PM EDT

Mark Emmert AP

You’re going to read a lot of words about the NCAA’s report on an external investigation into how they handled their own investigation into Miami and the accusations made by former booster and Ponzi-schemer Nevin Shapiro, but there is really only one line that you need to pay attention to:

The external review found that the NCAA enforcement staff “did not violate a specific bylaw or law.”

To recap:

– The NCAA hired Shaprio’s attorney, Maria Elena Perez, and paid her more than $18,000 (for more than $57,000 worth of work) specifically for the ability to sit in on and provide questions for depositions given under oath. The NCAA doesn’t have subpoena power.

– This happened, according to NCAA president Mark Emmert, despite the NCAA’s General Counsel directly telling the enforcement staff — specifically, investigator Ameen Najjar and his direct superiors, Julie Roe Lach and Tom Hosty — multiple times NOT to do to so.

– Najjar and Roe Lach have lost their jobs with the NCAA as a result.

–┬áRichard Johanningmeier, the investigator that was involved with the Todd McNair and USC investigation, spent $8,200 — $4,500 of which went directly into Shapiro’s commissary account in prison — to interview him in prison. He even bought a burner, a disposable cell phone, to get in touch with Shapiro.

– More than 20% of the information gathered during this process has been determined to be tainted and will not be used as the NCAA furthers their case against Miami.

– John Duncan, a Kansas City attorney that has been named the interim Vice President of Enforcement, is currently representing the NCAA in a case against a former coach at the University of Buffalo.

And there wasn’t a single violation of a specific bylaw or law throughout the entire investigation into Miami?!?

How is that possible?

What makes matters worse is that all of this is happening while the NCAA is already dealing with enough turmoil to make Mark Emmert regret ever taking over the role as president of the NCAA. One investigator was fired after her boyfriend spent a plane ride detailing how Shabazz Muhammad was never going to be allowed to play college basketball. A judge used the terms “ill will or hatred” and “reckless disregard for the truth” in regards to the NCAA’s investigation into McNair.

Isn’t this the definition of a lack of institutional control?

The investigative arm of the institution is ignoring the directives provided by the legal arm, instead hiring lawyers to use their subpoena power and paying witnesses for access to their information all while developing quite the reputation for malicious and vindictive investigations.

Failure to monitor, indeed.

That’s precisely why you are going to hear people call for Mark Emmert’s job and for a complete overhaul of the NCAA, and not just the enforcement arm. Is Emmert really this clueless as to what is going on in his organization? Jim Isch, who is more-or-less the second most important person in the NCAA, actually approved the payment that Roe Lach made to Shaprio’s attorney. ESPN.com reported earlier that General Counsel Donald Remy was aware of and approved the payment, as well.

And yet, none of this was actually a violation on any NCAA bylaw.

That’s a problem that may be bigger than the fact that Emmert apparently has no control over anyone that works for him.

I think it may be time to simply scrap it all and start over from scratch.

You can find Rob on twitter @RobDauster.

Latest Posts
  1. Former Oklahoma State guard suing university, head coach Travis Ford

    Sep 4, 2015, 9:24 PM EDT

    AP AP

    Stevie Clark, a four-star recruit, played only 16 games for the Cowboys.

  2. Ex-Syracuse signee Moustapha Diagne awaiting a student visa in Senegal

    Sep 4, 2015, 8:19 PM EDT

    Kelly Kline Kelly Kline

    Moustapha Diagne decided he would attend junior college back in August.

  3. Seventh Woods down to three schools, sets official visits

    Sep 4, 2015, 6:39 PM EDT

    Kelly Kline Kelly Kline

    Seventh Woods removed one more team from consideration.

  4. Wyoming guard Trey Washington III ‘day-to-day’ with knee injury

    Sep 4, 2015, 4:03 PM EDT

    Wyoming v UNLV Getty Images

    Washington sat out all of last season due to a lingering foot injury.

  5. Reigning national champions to visit White House Tuesday

    Sep 4, 2015, 3:21 PM EDT

    Mike Krzyzewski AP

    Mike Krzyzewski will be taking a national title team to the Oval Office for the fifth time in his career.

  6. Former Indiana forward’s marijuana possession citation dropped

    Sep 4, 2015, 12:39 PM EDT

    Landon Atterberry Devin Davis AP

    Devin Davis has since enrolled at Odessa JC in Texas.

  7. Former New Mexico guard signs with Australian Football League franchise

    Sep 4, 2015, 9:40 AM EDT

    Hugh Greenwood AP

    Greenwood is the second former college basketball player to sign with an AFL franchise in the last week.

  8. Gonzaga once again puts together a formidable non-conference schedule

    Sep 3, 2015, 9:05 PM EDT

    AP AP

    The Bulldogs are guaranteed games against five NCAA tournament teams and could play more based upon what happens in the Battle 4 Atlantis.

  9. Virginia announces addition of four-star forward, will redshirt

    Sep 3, 2015, 7:56 PM EDT

    mamadi diakite

    Virginia is trying to figure out the academic situation of Mamadi Diakite, who might enroll in 2015.

  10. Ongoing investigation results in Minnesota athletics administrator taking leave of absence

    Sep 3, 2015, 6:51 PM EDT

    University of Minnesota University of Minnesota

    This comes less than a month after AD Norwood Teague stepped down for his own alleged sexual misconduct.

  11. Shin issue to sideline Mississippi State freshman forward two months

    Sep 3, 2015, 5:22 PM EDT

    Ben Howland AP

    Joe Struggs, who didn’t enroll until last month, has been dealing with issues with both of his shins.

  12. Throwback Thursday: Juan Dixon and company win Maryland’s lone national title

    Sep 3, 2015, 4:15 PM EDT

    Juan Dixon #3 of the University of Maryland holds the ball Getty Images

    This year’s Terrapins will look to match what Dixon, Steve Blake and company accomplished just over 13 years ago.

  13. Mixtape of Rivals150 Class of 2016 guard Jalen Johnson (VIDEO)

    Sep 3, 2015, 3:30 PM EDT

    jalen johnson

    Jalen Johnson is one of the best in-game dunkers in the Class of 2016.

  14. Atlantic 10 releases full conference schedule

    Sep 3, 2015, 1:20 PM EDT

    Bob McKillop AP

    The Atlantic 10 released its full conference schedule. The league has 33 games on NBCSN this season.

  15. Michigan State sees remodeled practice facility after returning from Italy (VIDEO)

    Sep 3, 2015, 12:00 PM EDT

    Tom Izzo, Alvin Ellis III AP

    Michigan State saw the newly-renovated practice facility when they arrived back from a trip to Italy.

  16. Four-star power forward/center verbally commits to North Carolina

    Sep 2, 2015, 10:05 PM EDT

    Roy Williams AP

    With two seniors in their current front court, adding a big man helps North Carolina moving forward.

  17. St. John’s head coach Chris Mullin throws out first pitch at Mets game (VIDEO)

    Sep 2, 2015, 8:00 PM EDT

    AP Photo AP

    Mullin threw out the first pitch at a Yankees game back in late-May.