Skip to content

NCAA writes letter regarding addition of current athlete to O’Bannon lawsuit

Jul 11, 2013, 9:00 PM EDT

NCAA Men's Championship Game - Kansas v Kentucky Getty Images

With the ruling that the plaintiffs in the case of Ed O’Bannon vs. the NCAA, EA Sports and Collegiate Licensing Company would be best served to add a current student-athlete to its case, representatives stated that they would need the NCAA to guarantee that the student-athlete would not be punished for their participation.

Earlier this week the NCAA responded in a letter to Michael D. Hausfeld of Hausfeld LLP (lead lawyer for the plaintiffs), vehemently denying the assertion that a current student-athlete would be unfairly punished for joining the lawsuit.

To be perfectly clear to you, yet again, the NCAA has not and will not retaliate against any student-athlete because he or she participates in litigation against the NCAA, including your lawsuit. Indeed, there have been dozens of cases brought by student-athletes, none of whom have claimed retaliation by the NCAA. Your July 8, 2013 request for a stipulation regarding hypothetical “retaliation” against plaintiffs is completely unnecessary and, given the NCAA’s prior representations on this topic, offensive. There is no good faith basis for your contention that a current student-athlete participating in litigation against the NCAA has any worry of “retaliation, intimidation or coercion” from the NCAA. We have repeatedly made it clear to you in the course of this litigation that participation in a lawsuit against the NCAA has no effect on eligibility, and we can now only conclude that your letter has more to do with grandstanding for the press than actual concern for any potential current student-athletes seeking to join your lawsuit, or any attempt to move this litigation to a just conclusion.

The full letter can be read here.

The future status of the current student-athlete(s) has been a concern since U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken made the ruling that the plaintiffs would be allowed to make the addition before she decides whether or not the suit will receive class action certification.

But while the NCAA stated that it would not act in a malicious manner towards a current student-athlete that joins the suit, they did close the letter to Hausfeld with the following paragraph:

Finally, while the NCAA has no reason to believe that its member institutions, conferences, athletic departments or coaches would take any action against a current studentathlete who chose to participate in this litigation, we must again remind you that we represent only the NCAA and cannot speak (or sign stipulations) for NCAA schools, conferences, athletic departments or coaches who are not present before the Court. We have no basis or authority to make any representations on behalf of our member institutions, although we are not aware of any facts that would suggest that “retaliation” against a current student-athlete who joined your litigation would be a risk.

Essentially it’s the “well we won’t do anything, but if one of our members were to then that’s something you’d need to take up with them” angle. How much of an impact will that have on a current student-athlete’s willingness to join the lawsuit is the next question that will be asked in determining whether or not the plaintiffs can make the addition.

Ultimately Judge Wilken will make the decision as to whether or not this case should receive class action certification, with the plaintiffs hoping that she’ll grant the request.

h/t USA Today

Raphielle can be followed on Twitter at @raphiellej.

Latest Posts
  1. Tom Izzo performs with KISS cover band on stage at Michigan State’s Midnight Madness (VIDEO)

    Oct 24, 2014, 10:55 PM EDT

    tom izzo

    Tom Izzo does it again. Add it to the long line of amazing midnight madness entrances.

  2. Chris Mack and his daughters performed ‘Paul Revere’ by the Beastie Boys (PHOTO/VIDEO)

    Oct 24, 2014, 10:24 PM EDT

    Instagram/XU Athletics Instagram/XU Athletics

    Chris Mack and his daughters performed ‘Paul Revere’ at Musketeer Madness on Friday night.

  3. Wisconsin’s Sam Dekker injured at practice on Friday

    Oct 24, 2014, 8:05 PM EDT

    AP AP

    The Wisconsin forward is likely to miss a week or two

  4. Providence freshman forward, a top 100 recruit, is cleared to play this season

    Oct 24, 2014, 7:30 PM EDT

    Ed Cooley Ed Cooley

    Ed Cooley adds a 6-foot-8 forward to the Friars’ front court.

  5. Larry Brown talks about Ben Emelogu’s wavier to play this season (VIDEO)

    Oct 24, 2014, 6:45 PM EDT

    AP Photo AP

    The former Virginia Tech Hokie will be a big boost to SMU’s perimeter.

  6. Manhattan’s returnees look to build on the achievements of last season’s senior class

    Oct 24, 2014, 6:00 PM EDT

    Emmy Andujar and Shane Richards will be key players for Manhattan. (AP Photo) AP

    Manhattan and head coach Steve Masiello had some issues to address this spring, but thanks in part to their departed senior class the Jaspers are well-positioned to once again contend in the MAAC.

  7. Five-star 2015 power forward down to five schools

    Oct 24, 2014, 5:05 PM EDT

    cd0ymzcznguwzdbhnduynddiytjhm2yyzthlmtjjotqwyyznpti1yzy1ymy3ytizody1zwrhyzfhmme2odcxyjawntbi AP

    One of the nation’s highly-touted bigs is closer to making a decision after eliminating two programs from his list.

  8. LSU’s Johnny Jones receives raise, contract extension

    Oct 24, 2014, 4:22 PM EDT

    Johnny Jones AP

    Jones became the second coach to lead LSU to postseason appearances in his first two years this past spring.

  9. 2014-15 Season Preview: Rivals Iona, Manhattan have company in race to the top of the MAAC

    Oct 24, 2014, 3:00 PM EDT

    Manhattan's Steve Masiello (AP Photo) Manhattan's Steve Masiello (AP Photo)

    Rivals Iona and Manhattan are once again among the contenders, but they’ll have plenty of company in the race for the MAAC crown.

  10. UMass rewards Derek Kellogg with contract extension through 2018-19 season

    Oct 24, 2014, 1:52 PM EDT

    AP AP

    Kellogg’s led his alma mater to 21 wins or more in each of the last three seasons.

  11. Former Big East foes announce home-and-home series

    Oct 24, 2014, 12:39 PM EDT

    John Thompson III AP

    Georgetown holds a 35-29 lead in their all-time series with UConn.

  12. Top 25 Countdown: No. 11 Villanova Wildcats

    Oct 24, 2014, 12:30 PM EDT

    Getty Images Getty Images

    Villanova went 29-5 last season and return essentially the same lineup. Why aren’t more people talking about them?

  13. Four-star shooting guard verbally commits to Texas

    Oct 24, 2014, 12:13 PM EDT

    Rick Barnes AP

    Texas now has two four-star commitments, with Kerwin Roach joining Eric Davis on Friday.

  14. Three-star guard becomes Baylor’s fifth 2015 commitment

    Oct 24, 2014, 10:00 AM EDT

    Scott Drew AP

    Of Baylor’s five verbal commitments in the Class of 2015 four are guards, including their latest commit.

  15. Syracuse, NCAA Committee on Infractions meeting set for October 30-31

    Oct 24, 2014, 12:06 AM EDT

    Jim Boeheim AP

    Syracuse’s men’s basketball and football programs are under investigation, with the stakes being higher for Jim Boeheim’s program.

  16. Georgetown’s senior center looking to rebound from ‘embarrassing’ 2013-14 season

    Oct 23, 2014, 11:20 PM EDT

    Moses Ayegba, Joshua Smith Moses Ayegba, Joshua Smith

    Joshua Smith averaged 11.5 points per game before being ruled academically ineligible last season.

  17. Cameron Payne didn’t expect to fill Isaiah Canaan’s void at Murray State, but he did

    Oct 23, 2014, 10:49 PM EDT

    Cameron Payne (AP Photo) Cameron Payne (AP Photo)

    Cam Payne became the star of Murray State as a freshman, but he wouldn’t have gotten there if he had a back up. Why?

  18. VCU announces addition of 17-year old Morgan Vega to basketball program (VIDEO)

    Oct 23, 2014, 9:53 PM EDT

    Shaka Smart Shaka Smart

    The preseason favorites to win the Atlantic 10 added a new teammate Thursday.

  19. Junior guard decides to leave Charlotte program

    Oct 23, 2014, 8:03 PM EDT

    Demetrius Pollard, Shawn Lester Demetrius Pollard, Shawn Lester

    Shawn Lester averaged 11.9 points and 4.2 rebounds per game in the sixth man role last season.